What's the Difference Between 1099 vs. W2?

U.S. companies must inform the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) about payments made for services rendered by filing information returns. The classification of the service provider determines the specific type of information return utilised, whether they are an employee or an independent contractor. 

It is the responsibility of the business, on behalf of whom the services were performed, to submit the information return. These forms play a crucial role in ensuring that service providers accurately report their income and that the business fulfills its obligations in paying employment taxes for service providers classified as employees.

‍

1099 vs. W-2 Tax Forms

The primary contrast between the 1099 and W-2 forms lies in the information they capture:

• The 1099 exclusively documents payments made to independent contractors, with no reporting of tax payments.
• The W-2 serves as a comprehensive information return detailing taxable compensation for employees. It encompasses federal (and, if applicable, state) income tax, Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) withholdings, salary reductions for contributions to 401(k) plans and specific employee benefit plans, as well as other withholdings (such as for state disability benefits or paid family and medical leave benefits in particular states). It includes employee benefits like health cover, group term insurance, and dependent care assistance.

Form W-2 is utilised for reporting wages and other payments to employees, while Form 1099 is used for reporting payments to independent contractors. It is crucial for each business to classify its workers accurately as either employees or independent contractors to ensure the correct form is filed.

From the employer's standpoint, engaging independent contractors can be more cost-effective than hiring employees due to the savings in employment taxes, benefits, and administrative expenses. However, it's important to note that worker classification is not solely at the employer's discretion. 

A worker (in-house) is considered an employee (rather than an independent contractor) if the company exercises significant control over the work's when, where, and how. The IRS employs specific behavioral, financial, and relational tests to determine a worker's employment status for tax purposes.

In contrast, independent contractors are essentially self-employed individuals. They typically control their work schedule and methods, use their tools and equipment, and assume the risk of profit or loss on each assignment.

‍

What Is a 1099 Tax Form?

The 1099 tax form is an annual information return that outlines the total payments made to an independent contractor over a year. It is mandatory for businesses on whose behalf services were rendered to file this form if payments to an independent contractor reach or exceed $600 within the calendar year. However, it can still be filed for amounts below this threshold.

There are two primary types of 1099 forms that significantly impact employers: the 1099-MISC and the 1099-NEC. If you're grappling with the decision of when to use a 1099-NEC versus a 1099-MISC, the distinction lies in their purposes:

1. Starting from the tax year 2020, the IRS Form 1099-NEC is the designated tax form for reporting payments to contract workers in the previous tax year. It must be submitted to the IRS and provided to the contractor for income reporting.
2. The 1099-MISC, previously utilised for independent contractor payments, is now reserved for payments like royalties, rent, or those classified as other income.

What Is a 1099 Worker?

A 1099 worker, often known as an independent contractor, is an individual worker who provides services to a business under a contractual arrangement. 

Correctly classifying workers is crucial for businesses, and while seeking advice from an H.R. advisor or legal counsel is recommended for accurate classification, here are some examples of workers who might receive a 1099 form:

1. A consultant engaged for a specific duration to complete a project.
2. A freelance web developer working on a per-assignment basis, using their equipment.
3. An electrician contracted multiple times yearly to address power outages in an office building.

When To Issue a 1099?

Employers should issue a 1099 form to individuals or businesses that provide services but are not business employees. Independent contractors are often employed when projects or assignments have defined start and end times; there is no guarantee of continuous work, no set working hours, or the work can be carried out without direct supervision.

When Should 1099s Be Sent Out?

Per IRS guidelines, employers are obligated to issue a 1099 to independent contractors/workers who earned more than $600 in non-employment compensation by January 31 of the following year. Form 1099-NEC is distributed to the worker or business providing services and the IRS.

‍

What Is a W-2 Tax Form?

The W-2 tax form is an annual information return issued to employees by their employer. It details taxable wages, income tax withholding, and Social Security & Medicare tax withholding. 

Additionally, the form outlines various employee benefits, some taxable and some tax-free, and includes information on state income tax withholding. Businesses are required to file a W-2 for each employee, irrespective of the total compensation paid throughout the year.

What Is a W-2 Employee?

In tax terms, a W-2 employee is compensated through their employer's payroll, with payroll taxes deducted throughout the year. By January 31, the W-2 employee receives the Form W-2, which encompasses details regarding taxable compensation, tax withholdings, and potential deductions related to employee benefits like employer-sponsored health coverage or contributions to 401(k) plans. 

W-2 employees utilise this information to complete their annual tax filings. 

Examples of employees who typically receive a Form W-2 include:

1. An office worker with set hours, ongoing tasks, company-provided equipment, and direct supervision.
2. A warehouse supervisor with scheduled weekly hours and periodic training sessions.
3. An administrative assistant is required to be in the office from 9 am to 5 pm, with defined responsibilities and health insurance through an employer-sponsored medical plan.

When To Issue a W-2 Form

Employers are obligated to issue a Form W-2 to every employee who received payment during the year and had specific taxes withheld from their paychecks. Determining employee status versus independent contractor status depends on the nature and circumstances of the working relationship, as outlined in the IRS tests mentioned earlier. 

Generally, having W-2 employees implies ongoing work, the use of company-provided equipment, set working hours, and direct managerial oversight.

When Should W-2s Be Sent Out?

As per IRS guidelines, employers must provide a Form W-2 to every employee who worked for them in a given year by January 31 of the subsequent year. This deadline also applies to submitting copies of W-2s to the Social Security Administration (SSA).

‍

Is it possible for an Individual to Receive Both a W-2 and a 1099?

In specific scenarios, an individual may receive a 1099 and a W-2. For instance, if an individual holds a dual role as an officer and an employee within a corporation while also serving on the board of directors, they might receive a W-2 for employee compensation and 1099 for fees received in their capacity as a corporate director (a non-employee role).

Another circumstance where an individual could be issued both types of information returns by the same company in the same year is when an independent contractor providing services to the company transitions to an employee role during the year. In this case, the individual receives a 1099 for payments received as an independent contractor and a W-2 for payments made once they are added to the payroll. 

However, businesses need to exercise caution when changing the classification of a worker from employee to independent contractor or vice versa, especially if the individual continues to perform the same tasks under the new classification. 

‍

Filing 1099s vs. W-2s

The obligations associated with filing 1099s and W-2s for companies involve a dual process: distributing the original forms to the respective workers and forwarding copies to the government. Adhering to guidelines regarding the provision of these forms to workers is essential. 

For instance, an employer can electronically deliver a W-2 to an employee with prior consent, ensuring the consent is provided electronically to guarantee the employee's accessibility to the W-2 upon transmission.

When it comes to W-2s, electronic transmission to the Social Security Administration (SSA) is mandatory if the company issues 250 or more W-2s. 

However, smaller employers may opt for electronic filing as a time-saving and accuracy-enhancing measure. Accompanying the copies must be Form W-3. In cases where electronic filing is not employed, copies and a transmittal form must be mailed to the SSA.

Regarding 1099s, electronic delivery to independent contractors is permissible, provided they have consented. Electronic transmission to the IRS is mandatory if a company issues 250 or more 1099s. 

Employers utilising the Filing Information Returns Electronically (FIRE) system for self-filing must register to do so.

Although proposed regulations aim to reduce the electronic filing threshold for all information returns, these regulations still need to be finalised. Until they are officially implemented, the existing 250 threshold remains applicable.

‍

The Importance of Accurate Worker Classification for Employers with the IRS

It is crucial for small businesses to accurately classify their workers, as misclassifying an employee as an independent contractor can lead to significant consequences. The repercussions include the repayment of wages and employment taxes, substantial penalties, and potential liability for unpaid employee benefits, such as health coverage and retirement plan contributions.

The IRS imposes escalating penalties for unpaid employment taxes resulting from worker misclassification, typically covering a retrospective period of three years. 

In the case of failing to file a required Form W-2 in 2023, penalties range from $50 per form (if filed within 30 days post the due date) to $290 per form (if filed after August 1), with potential annual adjustments for inflation.

Additional penalties include:

1. Failure to withhold wages: 1.5% of wages, plus interest.
2. Employee's share of FICA: 40%.
3. Employer's share of FICA: 100%.
4. Failure to pay tax: 0.5% of the unpaid tax liability per month (up to 25 percent of the total tax liability).

If the IRS suspects fraudulent or intentional misclassification to evade employment taxes, penalties may escalate to 20 percent of wages paid, encompassing both the employee and employer shares of FICA. 

What Are the Key Deadlines for Filing W-2s and 1099s?

Both Forms W-2 and 1099 must be provided to the service provider by January 31 of the subsequent year following the year of payment (e.g., by January 31, 2024, for wages/compensation disbursed in 2023).

This same deadline applies to the submission of the forms to the government, whether through electronic means or on paper. January 31 marks the cutoff for forwarding copies of the documents, accompanied by a transmittal form, to:

1. IRS for 1099s: for reporting non-employee compensation (along with Form 1096).
2. Social Security Administration: for Form W-2s (along with Form W-3).

If a business is unable to meet the deadline, it can submit a request for a 30-day extension using Form 8809, but such an extension is not automatically granted. The IRS will consider a non-automatic filing extension under specific circumstances:

1. The business underwent a catastrophic event in a federally declared disaster area.
2. The company suffered a fire, casualty, or natural disaster affecting its operations.
3. Inevitable deaths, terminal illnesses, or the absence of the person/business owner required for filing the returns.
4. The information return is being filed for the initial year of the business's establishment.
5. The business owner didn't receive timely data on a third-party statement necessary for completing the form.

Furthermore, there is no provision for an additional extension of time to file beyond the initial 30-day extension. Penalties will begin to accrue once the extension period concludes.

Is a 1099 the Same as a W-2?

No, a W-2 and a 1099 are distinct forms, with the primary distinction being that a W-2 is issued to employees/workers on the company payroll, while a 1099 is provided to independent contractors and other non-payroll workers.

Can You File W-2 and 1099 Separately?

Individuals with W-2 income as employees and earnings as 1099 workers generally consolidate all this information when filing their personal tax returns. However, businesses issuing W-2s to employees and 1099s to independent contractors should file and submit copies to the respective government agencies individually. 

What Is the Tax Rate for 1099 vs. W-2?

For employers issuing W-2s to employees, they cover half of the Social Security & Medicare (FICA) taxes (7.65%), withholding the other half from employee paychecks per pay period. Independent contractors receiving 1099s are responsible for the total 15.3% self-employment tax on their earnings.

Why Is It Necessary To Have a W-2 or 1099?

W-2s and 1099s are essential because the information in these forms is utilised to report crucial data about earnings to the relevant government agencies. Employees need a W-2 to file federal and state taxes accurately. Independent contractors use information from 1099 to report income to the IRS and determine their appropriate tax liability. 

Chat with team Inkle on LinkedIn.